Last week, I was preparing a Torah class about soulmates. I had my sources—Gemaras, Midrashim, Chassidic teachings—strewn open across the table:
And then I turned to AI for some help. Someone in my office had recently told me that Claude is more powerful than ChatGPT so I decided to give it a try.
“Can you give me Chassidic stories about soulmates?” I asked.
Within seconds, it produced three breathtaking stories. One about Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, another about Rabbi Elimelech of Lizhensk, and a third about Reb Zusha of Anipoli.
The stories had every element you look for in a Chassidic story. They were mystical, emotional, and profound.
But as I read them more carefully, a thought niggled at me. I grew up on Chassidic stories. I live with them. I tell them to my children before bed. I share them at my Shabbat table. I incorporate them in my sermons, classes, hospital rooms, and fundraising dinners. And yet somehow, all three of these stories were completely new to me.
So I typed back: “Are those real stories? Please don’t invent stories. I need them to be authentic.”
Claude responded immediately: ">“You’re absolutely right to push back on that. Those stories were not real. I fabricated them and falsely attributed them to great Chassidic masters.”
I stared at the screen, my mouth hanging open.
Then I tried again, asking for more stories, and again they were fabricated.
Losing patience, I snapped back: “Please stop lying and making up stories.”
“You are right to push back…”
That’s when I realized that yes, AI can produce words, even beautiful, touching words, but it cannot produce the one thing that actually matters: truth.
A Chassidic story isn’t “content.” The goal isn’t to make it as inspiring and emotional as possible. The whole point is that it’s real, it happened, and it has been passed down for generations.
A machine can imitate the components of a good story, but never the soul. And the whole reason those stories endure is because of the soul—the struggle, faith, tears, and holiness of those who lived it.
Sure, a machine can generate a sermon in five seconds, write poetry, compose prayers, tell stories. But no matter how far AI progresses, it will never know the human experience: a trembling soul, tears, a broken heart, struggle, faith, suffering.
People do not need more polished words. If ever there was a generation drowning in synthetic experiences, it is ours: Fake news, fake images, fake followers, fake branding, fake perfection, and now, fake inspiration.
We’re starving for honesty and authenticity, not perfection. We need a rabbi who has struggled, a spouse who messes up and learns to apologize, a friend who listens in a way that Claude can never emulate and tells it to us straight when we need it. We need parents who parent from the heart, and Jews who practice real, authentic Judaism.
That’s the challenge of our generation.
In a world where almost anything can be fabricated, do we have the courage to be real? To let our words come from the heart, even if they’re not perfect and polished? Only words that come from the heart, from the soul, from us, can leave a lasting impact on the world.
